Gary E. Matthews, 78, and Monte J. Brannan, 67, both of Peoria, are charged with mail fraud, money laundering conspiracy, and money laundering. Brannan faces an additional three counts of concealment of bankruptcy assets. It is unclear if they have acquired legal representation.
According to a Department of Justice news release, Matthews is the founder of GEM Hospitality, a company created in 2008 to develop a hotel complex in downtown Peoria. Brannan became Matthews’ business partner in July 2011, when he bought 50 percent ownership of the company for $1 million.
The City of Peoria reportedly signed a redevelopment agreement with Matthews in 2008 that included the renovation of the Pere Marquette Hotel in downtown Peoria and the development of the Pere Marquette Courtyard Marriott Hotel. The project received $92 million in loans from a fund known as Indure, which was pooled from multiple sources, including local banks, the City of Peoria, and private investors. Mathews and Brannan were not to touch the funds except as “explicitly stated” in the lending agreements, sources indicate.
Marriott International managed both the Pere Marquette after it reopened in 2013 and the Pere Marquette Courtyard Marriott Hotel after its opening in 2014. Matthews and Brannan did not have access to the hotels’ revenues, so they worked to change that, the press release alleges. In 2014, Matthews allegedly attempted to take control by claiming that the Marriott was a poor manager, but the city rejected the proposal. However, the city agreed to execute a side letter amendment to allow Matthews to retain and manage First Hospitality Group of Rosemont.
The side letter amendment reportedly required Matthews and Brannan to file monthly compliance certificates with various stipulations, including one that prevented the pair from taking fee payments. The news release alleges that they filed only three certificates, all of which were false, and then stopped complying with that requirement altogether. Matthews and Brannan directed FHG to transfer monthly payments from hotel accounts to their accounts and used those funds for personal expenses, according to the indictment. Financial statements FHG sent to Indure were purportedly misleading and listed the payments as monthly rent, garage rent, franchise expenses, and Marriott rewards expenses.
Matthews and Brannan were allegedly aware that FHG could not pay for the hotels’ financial obligations, including payments to Marriott International and vendors. In June 2016, Marriott issued a notice of default for past due obligations of approximately $1.4 million. Matthews and Brannan didn’t respond to the notice and instead continued to transfer money to themselves, the indictment claims. They reportedly only made a payment in 2017 after Marriott shut off the hotels’ reservation system.
After Marriot issued the notice, Indure also issued a notice of default on its delinquent loan and filed a foreclosure action. The indictment claims Matthews and Brannan and their related businesses repeatedly delayed court proceedings while maintaining access to hotel funds. Even though they defaulted on loans and other duties, Matthews and Brannan purportedly continued to fraudulently transfer hotel revenues, diverting approximately $750,000 to themselves after the notice of foreclosure.
As a result of the scheme, Matthews and Brannan transferred an estimated $13.8 million of the hotels’ revenues to an account they controlled, and diverted approximately $1.6 million to themselves and their businesses. Brannan was additionally charged with concealment of bankruptcy assets after he allegedly filed for bankruptcy in April 2018 and failed to disclose bank accounts, a vehicle, and $80,000 in cash.
A court date for Matthews and Brannan has not yet been scheduled. The investigation was conducted by the U.S. Postal Inspection Service and the IRS – Criminal Investigation Division.
South Florida Fraud Defense Attorney